Saturday, January 10, 2015

So Much Reform, So Little Change: part 5

The Way Forward

The reality is that the students who need the most help tend to be in lower-quality schools, with larger classes, fewer resources, and with less-prepared and less-experienced teachers. Given the complexity of the problem, where should we begin?

A good place to start would be to recognize that in a low-performing school, everyone is working below capacity. These aren’t necessarily bad teachers, bad administrators or bad students. Everyone is dragged down by – as well as a contributor to - an organizational culture that expects little and is deeply resistant to change.

(As Payne points out, this concept of working below capacity also includes the attitude towards time. The typical view is that there’s never enough of it, but he argues that there should be a lot more discussion in policy circles on making better use of the time we already have.)

So, while there are a few interventions that have demonstrated some success regardless – for example, formative assessments for diagnosing student learning problems, and smaller class sizes, particularly in the early years – it appears that the best approach to school reform is to focus on interventions that are “tools for increasing district capacity”.

What that means is that, in bottom-tier schools, the first year or two of a new initiative should be more about building organizational infrastructure than about trying to implement anything specific. (Besides, the search for the one best educational model is probably a lost cause. Even if such a model exists, these schools lack the organizational capacity to implement any model with reasonable fidelity.)

First, you need a superintendent who understands organizational dynamics, ideally someone with experience in public education (including experience in the classroom!) Then, as Jim Collins might say, it’s about ‘getting the right people on the bus.’ How do we do that?  

It should be obvious that you begin by paying teachers a living wage. But more importantly, the focus should be on trying to create an environment that is attractive to the kind of teacher that you want in your school: a culture that respects and values teacher contribution; that provides opportunities for collaboration and meaningful professional development; in which teachers are supported by administration; and in which the needs of students are placed above the needs of the adults.

Once you have the right people on the bus, there are some things we have learned – or should have learned - from decades of reform efforts.  (The central problem in struggling schools appears to be an historic lack of adult learning.) Research findings from nearly 40 years ago told us that:
  •  training should be practical (not theoretical), teacher-driven and extended                    
    • one-shot, drive-by teacher training doesn’t work
  •  teachers should be provided with assistance in the classroom
  •  teachers should have opportunities to observe similar project in other schools
  •  teacher agency is strongly related to outcome
  •  there should be regular meetings focused on practical problems 
  • Principals should be active participants in the training.

In addition, research has shown that good implantation is more likely to occur:
  • in smaller (i.e., “manageable”) schools;
  • in schools where the focus is on strengths, not weaknesses (such as discipline problems, lack of student skills or parental support, etc.);
  • where there is a stable team of consultants providing whole school support.

Finally, here’s a key insight that we ignore at our peril: all of this takes time. Organizational reform can’t be rushed. In fact, when people who have led reform efforts were asked what one thing they would do differently, the most common answer was “take more time” – for planning, for training, for reflection. The unfortunate paradox is that time is something the children don’t have.

Friday, January 9, 2015

So Much Reform, So Little Change, part 4

The Dynamics of Organizational Change

Payne challenges the idea that it is possible to change these schools without making anyone do anything they don’t want to do. As he sees it, the fallacy of this idea is based on an assumption of a ‘rational’ organization; that is, if you show the education professionals a better way to do something, they will naturally adopt it. But this ignores the fact that once hopelessness takes root in an organization, the organization ceases to function rationally.

Observing this dynamic at work, it’s easy to label it as resistance to change, but Payne argues that this is not entirely accurate, either. It’s more skepticism than actual resistance, and it manifests itself in predictable ways. Veteran teachers – who have seen reforms come and go - are more likely to be uncooperative than newer teachers. It’s also not uncommon for relatively successful teachers to be resistant, because they’re already doing well, and they don’t need some outsider telling them what to do!

A common scenario looks like this: there’s one group of successful teachers who are split about a given reform, another group of younger teachers who are pro-reform, but who have little political clout within the system. (These are often elementary teachers who seem to have a genetic predisposition to accept change.) And then there’s a group of older, high-status teachers who are adamantly opposed. This last group often has disproportionate influence as to whether any change will be adopted, and they give legitimacy to the doubters.        

Another issue with the implementation of education research lies in the mindset of the university researchers who develop the model. Because they spend much of their time in the ivory tower, they often have little understanding of the real-world demands on teachers and principals. Worse, a deeply ingrained cultural assumption that places the university at the top of the educational food chain often leads to a sense of superiority, unjustified confidence in the reform model, and a lack of interest in practitioner knowledge! A former superintendent in New Jersey once commented that not one of the university developers he had worked with over the years had felt it necessary to strategize with school leaders before starting work.

A quality superintendent is essential to the success of any proposed reform. Unfortunately, the tenure of most urban superintendents is less than three years, which is not nearly long enough for a significant organizational change to take root, and certainly not long enough to actually begin to make a difference - which further reinforces the ‘this too shall pass’ organizational mindset. Also unfortunately, the next guy typically has no interest in building on the work of his predecessor; he’s got limited time to establish his own reputation!

This ignores research that indicates it typically takes about five years for a comprehensive school reform to produce sustainable results. What typically happens is that a new intervention shows some early promise (which gets everyone excited), and then there’s a slight dip as the initial enthusiasm wears off. Then just about the time everyone is getting on the same page and becomes comfortable with what they’re doing, there’s a change in administration, and we’re on to something else.

The other scenario (particularly when there’s serious grant money involved) is that under relatively ideal conditions, a new intervention shows promise. Under pressure from funders, the reform is then ‘brought to scale’ under less ideal conditions, with diluted support and, predictably, less impressive results - and the plug gets pulled. (Unless the funders are of an ideological bent, in which case evidence, or the lack thereof, isn’t important.)

An interesting factoid: in the year before Katrina wiped away the deeply dysfunctional New Orleans school district, said district had posted its best test scores ever.

On that note, Payne offers some interesting insight into how the ground was prepared for the Michelle Rhee reign of terror in Washington, D. C.  In addition to pervasive outright corruption, the best description of the school district prior to her administration was this outside analysis: “the district hasn’t done anything to improve student achievement.” When there’s nowhere to go but up, it engenders a willingness try anything.

This mentality of ‘anything would be an improvement’ can easily lead to investments in the simplistic and untested: closing of neighborhood schools, massive change-overs to charter schools, teacher evaluations via student test scores, etc..  Another manifestation of the ‘try anything’ mentality is the willingness to look for educational leadership anywhere except among educators! 

Unfortunately, this allows us to avoid thinking about the hard questions of instruction, human capital, and school culture - and it leaves us with a false choice between the entrenched politicized bureaucracy and ‘bold, radical’ transformation.

Tuesday, January 6, 2015

So Much Reform, So Little Change, part 3

'High expectations', Quality teachers & Professional development

There is similar nostalgia (see previous post) for Catholic schools, especially in urban areas. Historically, Catholic schools seem to do two things very well. One, there is a consistent message of high expectations; ‘no excuses’, if you will.  Two, explicit attention is paid to developing in students a sense of moral purpose. Students aren’t being educated for the sake of education, or just to acquire job skills. “Students are pushed to develop a moral vision towards which those skills should be pointed.” For the Catholic school, education does not exist in a vacuum; central to their mission is the idea that education is the means to fulfilling a higher purpose.

This brings us to the question of ‘high expectations’.  The degree to which students ‘invest’ in their education is greatly affected by their perception of what the learning environment appears to be asking of them, but this dynamic of high expectations is often misunderstood or misrepresented. Students may respond to demanding teachers, but only after the teacher has first established legitimacy, not only as a competent teacher, but as someone who genuinely cares for the student. It is not enough just to have ‘high expectations.’ 

Consider your own experience. I have no doubt that the teachers who ‘got the most out of you’ were not only ‘demanding’; they also expressed a genuine interest in you as a person.

It is therefore ironic that some (generally white) teachers mistakenly think that what ‘these kids’ really need is for someone to be ‘nice’ to them. Not that there’s anything wrong with being nice – nice is good!  Unless niceness is a stand-in for not expecting very much.

The quality teacher predicament is another issue that lacks an easy solution. Despite some positive rhetoric in policy circles about ‘placing teachers where they’re most needed’, I’ve yet to see a credible plan to address this. The problem is, we’d first have to repeal the law of supply and demand. Wealthy schools can afford to be picky; large urban schools with dysfunctional school cultures, not-so-much.  (Another problem is that states don’t hire teachers, school districts do.)

Making the matter worse, it’s hard for bottom-tier schools to keep the teachers they already have. Some of this is about money, but a lot of it is about school culture: lack of administrative support, lack of discipline, and the lack of teacher autonomy. But the challenge is greater than that. Even if you found a way to sprinkle in a handful of high-quality teachers, you may benefit a few students in the short term, but you’re not likely to change the overall culture of the school. Most likely, those teachers will eventually leave out of frustration, or adopt the norms of the school. Why?  Because the nail that sticks up tends to get hammered down. You’re making everyone else look bad!

It’s also important to note that ‘quality’ teachers don’t exist in a vacuum. A teacher’s ‘effectiveness’ is largely a function of the school environment. The best seed in the world won’t produce a good crop if the soil lacks nutrients and water!

Payne devotes an interesting chapter to the issue of teacher professional development. There are still many administrators who rely on the (albeit, inexpensive) model of ‘drive-by’ professional development: you send the teachers out to be ‘trained’ (or bring in an expert to deliver a lecture) and then send the teachers back into the classroom. This is based on a mindset that teachers are essentially interchangeable, programmable widgets, and shows little understanding of how adults actually learn. And so, even in places that have made arguably progressive investments in say, teacher coaching, you have administrators who don’t understand why coaches need time to collaborate, build relationships, or spend time in the classroom!  

In this model, it is the job of administrators to administer; it is, ironically, not part of their job description to understand how adults learn (as opposed to an organizational model in which principals are seen as ‘lead learners’). Which just highlights how important quality principals are to the educational capacity of a school.  

Tuesday, December 23, 2014

So Much Reform, So Little Change, part 2: the impact of race

Beginning with the first item on our list, (see previous post) one of Payne’s most disturbing observations about struggling schools is how quickly and early students are sorted into two categories: those who have potential, and those who don’t. This is often based on physical appearance, and prior to having any actual evidence! (In modern parlance, this is called having a ‘fixed’ mindset.)  Once so identified, teachers proceed to teach students differently, with higher quality interactions and higher expectations for the ‘smart’ kids.  This, of course, becomes reinforcing; the smart kids flourish (relatively); the ‘dumb’ kids begin to withdraw.

Then it gets worse. By the following year, the next teacher now has ‘data’ to back up her assumptions.  The effect on students is significant and long-lasting: research shows a high correlation between how students feel about their early years of public schooling and how likely they are to stay in school until graduation.

But there’s complicating factor at work here: low expectations on the part of teachers is not entirely unjustified. (Although the ‘sorting’ is.)  Years of experience have demonstrated to teachers that the barriers to success for these students is so high, that realistically, not many of them are going to ‘make it’. Teachers see the entire system as conspiring against their students. The administration is hopelessly inept (the average superintendent lasts less than three years) and the parents are unreachable. Why not invest your (unfairly) limited resources into the few kids who appear to have a chance?

Of course, such a view absolves teachers of responsibility for their role, and this mindset is a huge impediment to implementing systemic change. (That program may have worked where you come from, but it won’t work here, not with these kids!)  Payne refers to this as ‘racialist’ thinking. It’s not really racist in the sense that it isn’t a judgment as to genetic capacity - it’s not the kids’ fault, after all - but the impact is pretty much the same.  And this prejudging is just as common among Black teachers as White teachers.

Payne has a lot to say about race that is especially relevant in our current environment, and he spends an excellent chapter addressing one of the great mysteries of education policy: Why do Black students in relatively wealthy suburban schools not perform as well as their White counterparts? 

There is a common assumption – misunderstanding - by policy-makers is that race is essentially a stand-in for poverty, and that if you address issues directly relating to poverty, ‘race’ is not relevant. And while it is clearly important to address the issues significantly impacted by poverty– including physical health, parental support, the sense of emotional safety, as well as actual resources - the idea that Black students are essentially the same as everyone else, and that they will respond to an intervention in pretty much in the same way as everyone else, ignores the world we actually live in.

The problem is that our cultural environment is essentially poisonous for students of color. 

In our society, we tend to reduce the concept of racism to its most extreme manifestation; that is, when a ‘prejudiced’ persons discriminates in an explicit way. By that definition, racism really is largely a thing of the past; to act in a blatantly racist way has become culturally unacceptable. No one in the public eye gets away with it today. (Even the racists have to pretend not to be racists.)

Here’s one example of the insidious effect of cultural racism. There are years of studies demonstrating that in our society, Blacks are less ‘trusting’ than Whites. (Not surprisingly, since the more vulnerable one feels, the less trusting one tends to be.)  Now consider the impact of this on educational capacity, where the student-teacher relationship is so critical. For example, how willing is a student to ask for help if he’s afraid of reinforcing a cultural stereotype that ‘his kind’ isn’t particularly smart?  Most insidiously, over time, these perceptions get internalized.

But an even larger issue is the degree to which one “trusts the future”; that is, how much control do you think you have over your own fate? Again, not surprisingly, the degree of control that one believes one has is closely correlated to future achievement - more so “than all school-related factors put together.”

Further, this is not an irrational assumption. It is hard to argue that the system isn’t rigged. There are mountains of data that show Blacks are disproportionately disciplined for similar transgressions as Whites, both within the educational system, and without. What’s the point of making an effort if the system is rigged?  We cannot pretend that students are unaware of this.

This dynamic explains why immigrants from predominantly Black regions, such as Africa or the West Indies, often become more successful than African-Americans who have been here for generations. In their formative years, they weren’t poisoned by the cultural water.  A wise person once said, “The sins of the fathers are visited upon their children, even unto the third and fourth generation.”  Think about that. From the time that we begin to address an idea in our collective psyche as false and dangerous, it takes three or four generations to root out its detrimental effects. And that’s if we don’t go into collective denial and take a generation ‘off’.

This goes a long way to explain the ironic sense of nostalgia that many older Black Americans have for the kind of education they received during the ‘good old days’ of white supremacy, even with resources that were typically a third of their White counterparts. They remember those schools as “symbols of institutionalized caring” in which “building men and women” was seen as part of the school leader's mission – and which included an explicit challenge to the notion of racial inferiority. There is something about this education that many older Black adults now wish they could give to their grandchildren. What has been lost is so significant that some still believe that desegregation was a deliberate plot to break the spirit of Black communities. 

More summer reading: So Much Reform, So Little Change

 The Persistence of Failure in Urban Schools, Payne
(The first of several posts)

This is a wonderful, important book. In my view, it is especially important because our desire to move education policy away from the current obsession with standardized tests and misguided efforts at “accountability” - and into the 21st-centruy - is going to remain stuck (at least at the state and national level) until we figure out how to address “the persistence of failure in urban schools”.  Here are the ideas that I found most compelling.

Early on, Payne notes that most school “reform” interventions typically deliver considerably less than they promise, No Child Left Behind being the classic example. Over ten years after the initial legislation, it is hard to find anyone who still believes that NCLB will transform education - with the possible exception of those who are paid to believe it. (I saw this particular dynamic at work at a couple of recent PDE presentations at a PSBA conference.)  How does it go, “it’s hard to persuade a man of something when he is paid to believe otherwise?” (Upton Sinclair, more or less)

While this disconnect between theory and reality is sometimes explained by “political expediency or earnest incompetence”, the larger issue is that “people in leadership positions do not have a systemic understanding of the causes of failure.”  Put another way, discussions at the policy level are often –usually- completely disconnected from the daily reality of the classroom, particularly one in an urban school.

Although Payne shares the widely held concern about our overreliance on test scores, he makes the useful point that it’s very difficult to talk about large-scale change, particularly in bottom-tier schools, without referring to test scores. And while there are other useful ways of measuring progress, such as graduation rates and post-secondary achievement, test scores may have greater relevance in these schools. If over half of your students aren’t reading at grade level - as measured by test scores - that is a problem screaming to be addressed. If you’re at 92%, however, moving your scores to 94% may not be your highest priority.

He also suggests that we can learn a lot more from closely examining a few successful outliers to see what they’re doing differently, instead of looking for modest movements in overall averages - where it’s very difficult to tease out the components that are actually making a difference. In his view, we should be trying to determine the set of conditions that produce an environment conducive to significant improvement.

Here’s a key fact:  the degree to which teachers in a given school “trust one another” is highly correlated with whether the school is improving or stagnating. This is entirely consistent with over a decade of school climate research. “Do teachers care about each other?” “Is it safe to discuss frustrations and concerns?” It turns out that the culture of a school is far more important than how the school is organized.  Another critical factor is the level of trust and respect between teachers and principals.  It should be obvious, however, that there is no quick, easy way to create a climate of trust and collaboration.

Here’s another key point, one greatly at odds with most public policy initiatives: there is no magic bullet, no ‘one thing’ that will magically transform these schools. Rather, a lot of issues have to be addressed, all more-or-less together, because they are highly interrelated and any one of them has the potential to pull down a new initiative. 

     Here’s a partial list of what we’re up against:
·        Teacher skepticism about student learning capacity; fixed mindset
·        Weak pre-professional teacher training
·        Weak sense of teacher agency
·        Inadequate instructional supervision
·        Teacher isolation; unwillingness to accept leadership from other teachers
·        Drive-by, unfocused professional development
·        Disconnect between curriculum and assessment
·        Lack of discipline/ classroom management skills
·        Lack of teacher knowledge about students’ backgrounds and interests
·        Inadequate resources
·        Instability of instructional staff and leadership
And perhaps most importantly:
·        A generalized belief that nothing we could do will actually make a difference.

Tuesday, December 9, 2014

Tinkering Toward Utopia, part 2 – Lessons learned

So, what can we learn from a century’s worth of experiments in progressive, student-centered education?

One important ‘lesson learned’ is the importance of continuity in instructional leadership – many of these attempts were undermined by high principal turnover and teacher burnout. But perhaps the greatest fault of reformers has been in placing too much emphasis on persuading fellow education experts, and not enough on convincing the greater public of the importance and value of change – and a clear picture of what it might look like. People have a deeply embedded idea of what ‘real school’ is; changing that mental framework is no small task.

Student-centered reform is not the only educational policy to have run in cycles. Back in 1921, a school superintendent wrote, “We all agree that one teacher differs from another, yet few practical schoolmen have attempted to rate and pay them by merit, and most of those … have lived to repent of their rashness.” Teachers have (correctly, I believe) traditionally “viewed merit pay not as an incentive, but as a threat to professional comity” and irrelevant to the intellectual and social growth of their students. ‘Merit pay’ became fashionable in the 1950s, but had almost disappeared by the 1970s. And yet, here we are again.

The fundamental problem with making merit pay work is that there is little agreement on “just what effective teaching is and how to measure it.” Beyond that, promoting competition among teachers is likely to reduce productivity because it incentivizes teachers to conceal their best ideas, and to pursue their own interests rather than the general good.

Another problem is the deep disconnect between what teachers find most valuable in their profession, compared with public perception. In the public’s view, the two greatest concerns for teachers in 1981 were poor discipline and salary. For teachers, however, their greatest concern was the public’s perception of education! (Little has changed since 1981.) Salaries came in fourth. (As I’ve argued more than once, it’s not about the money, it’s about respect.)  The greatest motivating factor for teachers: the intrinsic rewards of seeing their students grow intellectually, and as people. If we really understood this, merit pay would seem like the silly idea that it is.

Reforms that fundamentally hope to alter the cultural construction of ‘school’ won’t succeed without a lengthy and substantial public dialogue about both the ends and means of schooling. (What is the 21st-century mission of the public school?)  The challenge is to negotiate a common ground of purpose sufficiently compelling that it unifies citizens in support of a renewed vision for public education.

One way we might approach this is to begin by asking people to recall their best experience as public school students. Invariably, they will recall the influence of a teacher who challenged them, made a subject come alive, or provided support at a stressful point in their lives. Which, come to think of it, aligns pretty well with what teachers identify as the most rewarding aspect of their profession. This suggests that the way to frame school reform is that we want to make such encounters between students and teachers more common.

A final note: it is essential that policymakers understand the limitations of what can be accomplished at the policy level. At best, education policy can set the conditions for effective administration and practice. The actual work has to be done by the administrators and teachers who interact with students on a daily basis. 

Monday, December 8, 2014

Book Report: Tinkering Toward Utopia

by David Tyack
Part 1 of my summer reading series

The Carnegie unit was established in 1906, and over a century later it is still the primary means of measuring student academic advancement. It was developed by an elite group of university presidents, who “confident that they had the answers to improving American education, were determined to reform from the top down a system of schooling they regarded as chaotic and ineffective.”  Since what’s good for the universities is good for the country, this system remains fundamentally in place even now.

The presidents group further determined that a minimum of 14 Carnegie credits should be required for university admission, as well as the content of these academic units - the reason most high schools still follow the traditional biology-chemistry-physics sequence. (And probably why we now have a biology Keystone exam graduation requirement.)  It’s also the main reason most high schools are still organized by content area departments. Much of the rigidity of the typical high school curriculum lies in this tie to college entrance requirements.

There have been challenges to this structure every twenty years or so, but none has really taken root because there is just too great of an investment in the current system. Interestingly - perhaps depressingly - a century of reform attempts will sound familiar to modern education progressives.

For example, beginning in the early 1920s, progressive educators in Denver objected to what they saw as domination by colleges of the secondary school program. Regarding the Carnegie unit as a straightjacket, they began to blend subjects, and experiment with time and space.  The Dalton Plan required “that teachers negotiate monthly contracts with their students.”  All students were required to study certain subjects, but it was the responsibility of the students to decide the pace of the work, who to work with, etc. No 50-minute periods, no ‘bells’, no teachers lecturing in front of large classes.

In the 1930s, the Progressive Education Association sponsored the Eight Year study. With a million dollars at their disposal, they were able to persuade over 200 colleges to admit students on a principal’s recommendation alone – GPAs and SATs not required. Freed from the ‘tyranny’ of the Carnegie unit, teachers developed curricula that crossed departmental boundaries, with less emphasis on traditional academic subjects and more time on the arts. Teachers spent less time lecturing, and more time planning – with each other, and with their students. Education became more individualized and student-centered. And much of this was accomplished using the ‘school within a school’ structure.

Any of this sound familiar?

Among the research findings from the study: graduates of these progressive schools did far better in college, on average, than their peers.  But by the early 1950s these reforms began to fade. Why?  The general consensus was that World War II and the specter of the Cold War brought a concern for security that strengthened the cultural tendency towards authoritarianism, in both society and in school. Compounding this, the passage of the GI bill allowed universities to become more selective in their admissions.

In the 1960s, yet another wave of reformers attempted to “overthrow the Carnegie unit … the teacher-dominated traditional curriculum, passive styles of learning, and the isolation of teachers from each other.”  And again, this idea seemed to have real potential, particularly for the most motivated and creative students.

It is interesting to note, however, that students who had already learned to succeed in a more directive environment often became frustrated when teachers no longer told them what to do. The greater flexibility that was a boon for some students was problematic for others.  In the public’s mind, this came to be seen as a ‘lack of discipline’, resulting in a desire to ‘get back to basics’. And so, in the 1970s the pendulum began to swing back again.

So, what can be learned from a century's worth of experiments in progressive, student-centered education?